Hello, fanfic readers!

How fitting is it that Supernatural comes back in October? Supernatural is (or used to be) one of the scariest shows on TV, so we could not pass the opportunity to dedicate one of Horror’s Fanfic Friday to the Winchesters. Next week will be horror anime, so make sure to send us your suggestions and fic recs!

For now, “enjoy” these 10 dark and creepy Supernatural horror recs!


the inexhaustible silence of houses

By: Askance
Summary: Almost two years after the world doesn’t end, Castiel falls from grace—and loses his voice in the process. It is the impetus for confession and change; before long, he is settling into a loving relationship with Dean, the Winchesters are tired, and hunting for a place to land has taken precedence to hunting anything else. Dean and Castiel fall in love with the strange little house on the end of Swallowtail Drive, and for a little while life is as it should be—sweet, affectionate, and beginning afresh. But more and more Castiel sees and hears things in the house that beg the question of whether or not a place itself can be alive. The walls and rooms seem to shift and grow and breathe, and one night, Dean comes home from a hunt changed in a way that Castiel cannot explain. In the months that follow, their domestic bliss takes turns for the dark and sour, and the confusion of their circumstances will ultimately test everything Castiel knows about the man he loves, and everything he believes to be true.
Rating: Teen and Up Audiences – Major Character Death – M/M – Horror, Psychological Trauma, Domestic Violence
Words: 31,820

On the Wings of War

By: AlchemyAlice
Summary: The four Horsemen are not just people with fancy rings. They aren’t even demons with fancy rings. They are another species entirely, a force unto themselves, and Lucifer is kidding himself if he thinks that they are at his beck and call. They are separate. They are neutral. Dean Winchester is not built like them.
Rating: Teen and Up Audiences – Graphic Depictions of Violence – M/M – Apocalypse, Biblical References, Blasphemy, Lovecraftian, Wingfic, Gore, Body Horror, Transformation
Words: 85,048

Sand

By: story_monger
Summary: Castiel finds sand in the shower drain and the sink drain, pinging against the hardwood in the kitchen, under his fingernails when he runs his hand through his scalp, between his teeth and under his tongue and caked on several eyelashes. He blames their location at first, but he hasn’t stepped outside for four days.
Rating: General Audiences – Gen – Season 11, Body Horror
Words: 1,519

C-S-T-L

By: komodobits
Summary: LJ DCBB 2013. It’s been nineteen years since the beginning of the Last War, and the Alliance Army is losing land faster than it can supply good men to defend it. Their hope is the synthesis of Android Angeles, a series of humanoid machines designed without the capacity to feel, and thus enabling them to be the perfect super soldiers. In order to check their battle suitability, the first prototypes are sent down with a landing party of the men they will later replace, and Sergeant Dean Winchester is paired with Unit 5284-C-S-T-L for the assignment. Cas, as Dean nicknames him, is easy enough to work with – once you get past the emotional vacancy and blatant disregard for human life, that is – but as the squad’s tour goes on, Dean gets to wondering whether the Android Angeles are really as unfeeling as he’s been told, or if the fear of a reality in which malfunctioning prototypes will be shut down is too great for them to exist any other way.
Rating: Mature – Graphic Depcitions of Violence – M/M – deliberate self-mutilation, minor gore, Body Horror, Deafness
Words: 90,377

Skin Like Fear

By: fantamae
Summary: It’s not that Dean doesn’t get that Sam doesn’t want to talk about whatever Hell did to him; Dean practically wrote the book on that particular brand of avoidance. Except that Sam doesn’t do this. Dean is supposed to clam up and Sam is supposed to pry and bleat about how “communication is good for the soul” or some shit. Sam is supposed to cry on his shoulder and Dean is supposed to stoically hold him and let him get it out, maybe shedding a manful tear or two in solidarity. Here’s the thing: Sam comes back from Hell with a bubble of space around him. He doesn’t want to be touched, especially by Dean, and he won’t explain. He won’t talk about Hell at all, and Dean’s going crazy. It’s going to take a strange case (and a little magic) in Michigan to break the floodgates, but when Dean finally learns the truth, he might wish that he hadn’t…
Rating: Explicit – Rape/Non-Con – M/M – Non-con between Sam and Lucifer, Hell Fic, Horror, Body Horror, Torture
Words: 18,762

To The Victor The Spoils

By: JinxedAmbitions
Summary: When the forces of Heaven and Hell met on the battlefield, the demons’ charge was led by the Knight of Hell wearing the face of the “Righteous Man.”
Rating: Mature – M/M – AU-Apocalypse, Knight of Hell Dean, Angel Castiel, Violence, Gore, mentions of torture, Body Horror, Dark fic
Words: 2,294

The Flock

By: museaway
Summary: A two-story structure stands out against a yellowed field. He didn’t notice it before.
Rating: Teen and Up Audiences – Gen – Psychological Horror, Fire, perceived death, Canon-Typical Violence, Birds, Mild Hurt/Comfort
Words: 11,071

Urban Legends

By: ShoshannaRose
Summary: Even before the Apocalypse began, there were whispers about John Winchester’s boys. By the time the Gates of Hell are closed, the Winchester brothers become every hunter’s living legend and every monster’s horror story.
Rating: Not Rated – F/M, M/M – Legends, Horror, Hell, Hunter Gossip, Multiple POV, Apocalypse, Purgatory, Monsters, Leviathans
Words: 5,577

Just Desserts

By: TardisIsTheonlyWayToTravel
Summary: Sam and Castiel decide to destroy Heaven, and Gabriel does absolutely nothing to stop them.
Rating: Mature – Gen – Horror, Angst, AU
Words: 5,229

For The End of My Broken Heart

By: Wickedtruth
Summary: Dad’s disappeared and Sam’s left to pick up the pieces of his broken brother. Post Devil’s Trap AU.
Rating: Explicit – M/M – First Time, Ghosts, John Finds Out, Horror, Haunted Houses, impala!sex, tattoos, Soul Bond
Words: 59,522


You wrote a fic and would like it to appear on Fanfic Friday? Or maybe you want to suggest a fic you loved? If so, let us know by leaving a comment down below, tweeting us, sending us an ask on Tumblr or emailing us!